dan rating system: Full Price
recommendation: No Chillins under 14
Ahh…my first review written on Rotten Tomatoes. That’s kinda fresh, right?
(note: I’m also posting this on my blogs…so don’t be confused my friends)
Listen, this movie has gotten a piss poor rap, and I can’t help but be reminded of Lady In The Water. I’m not an M. Night fanboy, but I do enjoy his work, so take what I say here with a grain of salt. That being said: this movie does not suck.
I still kind of agree with the consensus that it starts with promise and then degrades a little. Mr. Shyamalan would have done well to get an appointment with a script doctor on this deal. The story might have been better served being more about the love story between Elliot and Alma and less about, well, the happening. He very successfully did this in The Village, so I know he’s got it in him!
Spoilers Follow! Beware! BEWARE!!!
First, I’ll address the end. Had the love story been developed more, I would have felt more moved when they decide to be together despite threat of death. But even that scene itself felt pretty rushed and contrived. Both Mark Wahlberg and Zooey Deschanel are great actors, so I’m left to blame the writing, directing, and editing that made that scene so bad. Sorry Night. You’re cool and all, but it just didn’t quite get there.
The good? Well, there is certainly a Hitchcockian, looming, unseen terror throughout the film. And despite what others have said, I think that throwing the gore factor into this one was a good decision. It fit. There was some pretty traumatic imagery that the movie would have felt incomplete had it not been there. There was a little bit o’ comic relief that worked as well, so I literally laughed between moments of fear.
Also, I do appreciate his treatment of his characters. M. Night always seems to put a lot of care in birthing them; as though they are his very children. I like that in a writer. Maybe the character development was a bit off in this one, but it doesn’t mean that he didn’t care. Maybe he just forgot.
Unfortunately, the bad is glaringly bad. I’ve already mentioned the lack of a central plot device (or did I? well, there is a lack of a central plot). But there were also some dangling participles that I thought were completely unnecessary and made this feel more like a sophomoric effort than someone’s 9th film. LIke the little boys getting capped on the crazy old man’s porch. I mean, I get shock value, but all I ended up thinking is WTF???
And dude…is it just me, or is this picture incredibly preachy? M. Night attacks environmental apathy, emotional apathy, detachment, anger, and the list goes on and on. By the end, I didn’t know if I was supposed to love my neighbor, invest in solar energy, or cut down my tree swing. There really shouldn’t have been an underlying moral to this story; I don’t think Al would have approved.
Not that Al. He probably would have approved.
Again, overall, I still think this was a fun movie. It scared me and that’s what I wanted. I said this about the rest of his followups to The Sixth Sense, and I’ll say it again: if you expect this to be that, then you’re going to be incredibly disappointed. MNS has a style. He takes other genres and pulls them into the thriller genre and it works (think about it. he’s done a ghost story, a superhero movie, an alien movie, and now a horror film. He adapts them to his flavor, and it works. I just wish he’d get some help on his scripts.
Oh yeah, the Dan rating system and recommendations. I give it a Full Price rating if you’re not going to poo poo on the fact that this isn’t his best work. And I wouldn’t take your nino’s to see it unless they’re over 14. There’s some pretty scary imagery that could cause some serious nightmareage. Get it? NIGHTmareage?
Tags: M.Night Shyamalan, The Happening, movie review